Last season, in the seventh minute of stoppage time, the 31-year-old forward was brought down in the area deep into injury time and moments later, he decided to step up and take the spot kick at the City Ground.
Many would crumble under the pressure but Taylor stepped up confidently to secure his side their first home win in eight games. And when I say confidently, I mean the most relaxed penalty run-up ever.
He casually walked to the 12-yard line before sending goalkeeper Marko Marosi the wrong way. "The coolest man. The most composed man in the City Ground," the commentator said, almost taken aback by the sheer audacity of his run-up. "How does he take his penalties like that?"
Talk about having ice in your veins.
Of course, this isn't the first time Taylor has converted like this in such a high-pressure situation.
During the 2019/20 campaign, when he was playing under Lee Bowyer at Charlton, the confident striker played a huge part in a game against Barnsley, when his side were handed a last gasp penalty after a close encounter at Oakwell.
Barnsley were 2-1 up thanks to goals from Cauley Woodrow and Conor Chaplin but a foul from defender Bambo Diaby on highly-rated midfielder Conor Gallagher handed The Addicks a lifeline in the 90th minute.
And that man Taylor converted from the spot in a typically calm fashion, despite boos from around the stadium.
After that game, Charlton manager Lee Bowyer admitted that he "didn't fancy" Lyle Taylor to score.
"To be fair, I didn't fancy Lyle to score! When he's walking up to take the penalty I didn't fancy him to score, but obviously he does. He's so calm in that situation and he's the person you'd want to be taking the penalty so, thankfully, it went in."
Is this the coolest penalty technique you've ever seen?
Let us know in the comments.
- Man Utd striker hailed as a "fighting machine" by club legend after Nottingham Forest win
- Nottingham Forest Want To Sign Dutch Striker Jizz Hornkamp, It's The Greatest Name In Football
- Neville says Ten Hag was "fuming" with Man Utd star for moment in Nottingham Forest win
- Nottingham Forest Hero Brice Samba Had Penalty Instructions Taped To Hidden Water Bottle