Ferdinand and Lescott at loggerheads in Casemiro vs Rodri debate - ‘More than a footballer…'

Manchester United legend Rio Ferdinand debated former Manchester City star Joleon Lescott about whether Casemiro was better than Rodri.

City dispatched Liverpool 4-1 at the Etihad to apply the pressure on title rivals Arsenal.

But before the game former United centre-back Ferdinand was caught in a debate with Lescott regarding who was the better holding midfielder - Casemiro or Rodri.

Brazil international Casemiro has been a transformative presence for Erik ten Hag’s side in his debut campaign in English football. Meanwhile, Rodri has been one of the outstanding midfielders in the Premier League since joining City from Atletico Madrid in 2019.

But the question of who has impressed more divided pundits on BT Sport, with Lescott opting for the Spaniard and Ferdinand backing the United star.

Casemiro or Rodri?

Naturally, Ferdinand threw his support behind Casemiro. The former United star said: “I would take Casemiro because I think the impact he has had is huge.

"He’s more than a footballer, he’s a leader on that pitch.

“With the experience he’s got and what he’s won as well, it just elevates him above at this stage. But Rodri is a fantastic footballer.”

Speaking about Rodri, Ferdinand added: “When the ball turns over, he’s one of the first people there to slow that transition down or intercept, so other players can get back. He will dictate that.

“But also, third-most carries of any midfielder in Europe shows you he’s not just a one-trick pony, he does difference facets of the game remarkably well.”

Lescott, who has claimed two Premier League winners medals with City, argued that Rodri was the superior player.

He said: “I would [take Rodri over Casemiro]. Casemiro has been impactful for Man Utd, but from a centre-half’s point of view, and what I want them to do, I think he prevents a lot of opportunities for the opposition.

“He recognises the danger so early, so the attacks don’t even start. I would definitely put him ahead of Casemiro – it’s not just my biased Man City hat on!

“I think he’s the most adaptable in that role. I think Sean Dyche would sign Rodri.

“He’s a personality as well, he’s not on social media, I think that goes a long way – he’s low maintenance, but so impactful on the pitch.”

Topics: Football, Rodri, Casemiro, Manchester United, Manchester City, Rio Ferdinand, BT Sport

Chris Byfield

Sport journalist with experience writing on football, rugby, boxing and the Olympics. I'm also a Crystal Palace fan. Please don't hold this against me.