To make sure you never miss out on your favourite NEW stories, we're happy to send you some reminders

Click 'OK' then 'Allow' to enable notifications

Not now

4K image proves controversial Japan goal vs Spain was right to stand

Josh Lawless

| Last updated 

4K image proves controversial Japan goal vs Spain was right to stand

A 4K image released would appear to prove that Japan's controversial winning goal against Spain was right to stand.

Alvaro Morata put Spain 1-0 up in the 11th minute but then Ritsu Doan levelled matters just after half-time. Minutes later and Japan, who had just 17 per cent possession, were in dreamland when Ao Tanaka completed the turnaround.

The goal was initially chalked off as it appeared as though the ball had gone out of play when Brighton's Kaoru Mitoma crossed for Tanaka on the stretch.


However, a lengthy VAR check resulted in referee Victor Gomes awarding the goal. It meant four-time winners Germany, despite their 4-2 win over Costa Rica, were eliminated at the group stages for the second consecutive tournament.

The initial images shown by broadcasters made it seem as though the ball was over the byline.

However, angles can deceptive and a 4K picture posted showed that it was in fact in by the slightest of margins.

As stated by Dale Johnson for ESPN, The law is that the the ball is in play "if the curvature of the ball is over the line", irrespective of how small a part of it is.

Despite the Adidas ball for the tournament having motion sensors that can be used to track data and semi-automated offsides amongst other things, it does not have the ability to check whether the ball has gone out.

Instead, it was the goal-line camera which provided the evidence required for the reversal of the decision.

Image: Alamy
Image: Alamy

The ball does appear to be overhanging the line - something we often see when players take corner kicks and it looking like it isn't in the quadrant.

That was the grounds for the goal being given and seeing Japan progress to the round of 16 as group winners on six points.

Explaining the call on ITV, former Premier League referee Peter Walton said: "There’s a misconception in law that just because the part of the ball that is on the floor is over the line is out - well it clearly isn’t because it’s the curve of the ball. We see it often with corner kicks where it’s over the line but not quite over the line.

"In this instance, what the VAR is looking for is the evidence to suggest to the referee that the ball has clearly left the field of play and on the evidence that we’re seeing, he doesn’t have that in front of him."

Germany were dumped out, with Spain finishing second thanks to a superior goal difference achieved in that 7-0 thrashing of Costa Rica.

Japan will take on Croatia on Monday, with Spain playing Group F winners Morocco in the knockouts a day later.

Featured Image Credit: Associated Press & Bleacher Report

Topics: Japan, Germany, Spain, Football World Cup

Josh Lawless
More like this

Chosen for YouChosen for You


Moises Caicedo publicly declares he wants to leave Brighton following £60 million bid from Arsenal

8 hours ago

Most Read StoriesMost Read

'Get out of my club' - Arsenal fans have identified where the game was lost vs Man City

10 hours ago