To make sure you never miss out on your favourite NEW stories, we're happy to send you some reminders

Click 'OK' then 'Allow' to enable notifications

Not now

Premier League Strikers Ranked From ‘GOAT’ To ‘Not A Footballer’

Alex Reid

| Last updated 

Premier League Strikers Ranked From ‘GOAT’ To ‘Not A Footballer’

Sergio Aguero has been named the greatest Premier League striker ever, while Gabriel Jesus, Anthony Martial and Roberto Firmino are labelled 'Overrated'.

SPORTbible used TierMaker to rank current outright strikers and, while Aguero has had injury issues this season, he is the Premier League's deadliest ever finisher. No forward can match his astonishing ratio of a goal every 106 minutes.

Harry Kane, who recently joined Aguero in the 150 Premier League goals club, is in the next tier down. The Spurs star is 'Elite' alongside Jamie Vardy, Pierre-Emerick Aubameyang, Marcus Rashford and Timo Werner (early days, but the Germany international is showing his class).

But controversially labelled 'Overrated' are Jesus, Martial and, yes, even Bobby Firmino.

None of them are bad players. But Liverpool's Firmino has definitely fallen into the category of being called "underrated" so often, he's become slightly overrated. Yes he's unselfish, but how hard is it really when Mo Salah and Sadio Mane are either side of you?

Jesus hasn't quite developed into the Aguero replacement Man City hoped he'd be yet, while Martial is a frustration. The Man United striker looks world class on his day, but remains inconsistent.

On the other side of the coin, Olivier Giroud is a long-time 'Underrated' player. A selfless link-up man with 86 Premier League goals, Arsenal and Chelsea both casually chuck Giroud aside despite his ability to score worldies out of nowhere. Harsh.

Michail Antonio is also labelled 'Underrated' having developed into a fine forward, as is Wolves' Raul Jimenez who plenty of people rate but still not highly enough for us. This No 9 can do it all.

Dominic Calvert-Lewin and Danny Ings and simply 'Good' for now, however both are performing so superbly they're on the verge of smashing upwards through the tiers.

Elsewhere, 'Poor' contains some real forward flops of the Premier League era. Wesley at Aston Villa, Joelinton at Newcastle, Islam Slimani at Leicester - no. Sebastien Haller has shown flashes at West Ham but not enough to justify the reported £45 million transfer fee.

Without wishing to be cruel, Andy Carroll and Christian Benteke are bottom. Carroll is more than just a goalscorer, of course. But he hasn't netted in 22 league games since Newcastle re-signed him in 2019. His last Premier League goal came in April 2018, back when Arsene Wenger was still Arsenal boss, and Huddersfield Town and Cardiff City roamed England's top tier.

Benteke is a mystery. A striker with 38 caps (and 15 goals) for Belgium currently playing like he'd struggle to get into a San Marino XI. Poor lads, let's hope they both find their shooting boots ASAP and shut us right up.

The full SPORTbible rankings are below.

GOAT: Sergio Aguero

Elite: Harry Kane, Jamie Vardy, Pierre-Emerick Aubameyang, Marcus Rashford, Timo Werner

Underrated: Raul Jimenez, Olivier Giroud, Michail Antonio, Neal Maupay

Good: Dominic Calvert-Lewin, Danny Ings, Callum Wilson, Tammy Abraham, Patrick Bamford, Chris Wood, Michy Batshuayi, Ashley Barnes, Lys Mousset, Ollie Watkins, Che Adams

Overrated: Gabriel Jesus, Roberto Firmino, Anthony Martial, Aleksandar Mitrovic, Alexandre Lacazette

Poor: Wesley, Cenk Tosun, Joelinton, Islam Slimani, Divock Origi, Kelechi Iheanacho, Oli McBurnie, Sebastien Haller

Not A Striker: Andy Carroll, Christian Benteke

Let us know what you think of our Premier League striker rankings in the comments.

Featured Image Credit: PA Images/TierMaker

Topics: Gabriel Jesus, Football News, Anthony Martial, Michail Antonio, Sergio Aguero, Football, Roberto Firmino, Raul Jimenez, Premier League, Olivier Giroud, Harry Kane

Alex Reid
More like this

Chosen for YouChosen for You


“Terrible” Liverpool star slammed after dismal horror showing against Wolves

2 hours ago

Most Read StoriesMost Read

Casemiro sent off for putting his hands around Will Hughes' neck in moment of madness

2 hours ago