Current Premier League Goalkeepers Ranked From ‘GOAT’ To ‘Not A Keeper’
Liverpool's Alisson Becker has been named the greatest goalkeeper in the Premier League, while David de Gea sits in the 'overrated' category.
SPORTbible's TierMaker ranking looks at the current crop of keepers and it's clear that Alisson is No 1 - a complete keeper, reliable and great with his feet. Given time, he'll be competing with Peter Schmeichel for Premier League best-ever status.
Just below in the 'elite' tier sits the man Alisson keeps out of the Brazil team - Ederson - Wolves' Rui Patricio, plus Kasper Schmeichel, who Leicester have done well to hang on to.
Unfortunately topping the 'overrated' tier is Manchester United's De Gea. The league's best keeper for a four-year spell, his dodgy form is sometimes referred to as a blip - but it's been three mistake-filled years for the Spain international. Bizarre as he approaches what should be his peak.
He's joined by Tottenham's Hugo Lloris, who can be superb but remains unreliable, and Jordan Pickford who makes too many errors for a keeper who's first-choice with Everton and England.
Below even that is the world's most expensive goalkeeper, Kepa Arrizabalaga, who's been a £71.6 million disasterclass. Worryingly for Chelsea fans, the 25-year-old also seems to be going backwards rather than getting better.
Higher up the ranking, Newcastle's Martin Dubravka, Crystal Palace's Vicente Guaita and Brighton's Maty Ryan are all categorised as 'underrated'. These solid stoppers don't get much credit outside of their own fanbases, while Nick Pope is starting to - but still doesn't get quite the praise he deserves.
The 'good' category sees a mix of young keepers with serious potential such as Dean Henderson and Aaron Ramsdale. Plus players such as Arsenal's Bernd Leno who we need to see a bit more of as, frankly, not all Gunners fans are fully convinced he's better than the departed Emiliano Martinez.
At the bottom of the scale, we have Loris Karius (yes, he's still at Liverpool). No wish to be unkind to a 27-year-old with (a lot of) room to improve, but the contrast between him and his replacement at Anfield is blatant. Also, there's Kyle Walker, who is more literally 'not a keeper'.
More Like ThisMore Like This
The full SPORTbible rankings are below.
Elite: Ederson, Rui Patricio, Kasper Schmeichel
Underrated: Martin Dubravka, Nick Pope, Vicente Guaita, Lukasz Fabianski, Maty Ryan
Good: Bernd Leno, Dean Henderson, Aaron Ramsdale, Sergio Romero, Alex McCarthy, Marek Rodak, Emiliano Martinez, Illan Meslier, Kiko Casilla
Overrated: David de Gea, Jordan Pickford, Hugo Lloris
Poor: Kepa Arrizabalaga, Joe Hart, Adrian Willy Caballero, Paulo Gazzaniga, Sam Johnstone, Angus Gunn, Wayne Hennessey
Not A Keeper: Loris Karius, Kyle Walker
Let us know whether you agree or disagree in the comments.
All imagery: PA Images/TierMaker